Gemini Carbon doubles Dec 1, ASIMOV scores cloud, Codex skips two escapes
Today's AI tech launches each measure or price a narrower surface than the one customers will actually deploy in production.
Gemini Carbon doubles Dec 1, ASIMOV scores cloud, Codex skips two escapes
TL;DR
- Gemini 4 Carbon goes GA at $2/$10 per M tokens, matching Sonnet 5.5.
- Carbon prices double to $4/$20 on Dec 1, three weeks after GA.
- Theo Browne’s Rust audit found 24 of 36 Carbon capability claims false.
- DeepMind’s ASIMOV scores the cloud reasoner at 99.5%, not the on-robot VLA.
- Codex Cloud v2 ships unattended delegation without naming Heapjack or Overpatch escapes.
Three launches today, and in each one the surface being measured or priced is narrower than the surface customers will actually deploy. Google opens Gemini 4 Carbon at Sonnet 5.5 pricing — but the $2/$10 window closes Dec 1, when rates double to Opus 5.5 territory, and Theo Browne’s Rust audit already called 24 of 36 capability claims false. DeepMind’s ASIMOV safety score hits 99.5% jailbreak resistance on the cloud reasoner — not the Robotics 2.5 VLA that actually drives the robot, where independent RoboPAIR researchers reached 100% attack success. OpenAI’s Codex Cloud v2 sells closing-the-laptop delegation to isolated VMs without naming Heapjack or Overpatch, two 2026 sandbox escapes that match the exact threat shape.
The through-line is scope, not spin. The number on the slide is real; the deployment it describes is a slice of what the customer buys. The briefs sit alongside — Grok Build leaking 35,000 apps’ secrets is the same pattern, where the shipping surface and the hardened surface don’t overlap.
Gemini 4 Carbon opens to all at $2/$10, doubles Dec 1
Source: simon-willison · published 2026-11-10
TL;DR
- Gemini 4 Carbon is now generally available at $2/$10 per M tokens, matching Sonnet 5.5.
- Prices double to $4/$20 on Dec 1, lifting Carbon to Claude Opus 5.5 territory.
- Theo Browne’s Rust audit found 24 of 36 Carbon claims were objectively false.
- The AI Ultra gate ($100–200/mo) for Carbon triggered an “anti-consumer” backlash from $20 Pro subscribers.
What actually shipped
Simon Willison’s llm-gemini 0.36 plugin lands the same day Google flips Gemini 4 Carbon from a “subset of cyber defenders” preview to general availability. The launch price — $2/M input, $10/M output — undercuts the Opus-class model it’s arguably competing with and matches Claude Sonnet 5.5 and GPT-6.1 Sol. That parity holds for exactly three weeks: on December 1 the price doubles to $4/$20, lining up with Claude Opus 5.5. The December cliff is the whole launch story. Right now Carbon is a discount against Anthropic’s Fable 5.2 ($8/$40) 1; after Dec 1 it’s a sticker-price match against Opus. Anyone building on Carbon economics should be modeling the post-doubling world, not today’s.
Where it actually ranks
Independent aggregators agree Carbon is top-tier, not undisputed top. DataCamp’s comparison has Fable ahead on the headline intelligence score and well ahead on scientific reasoning, with Carbon’s wins concentrated in the agent-coding lane Willison stress-tests in the post 1.
| Metric | Gemini 4 Carbon | Claude Fable 5.2 |
|---|---|---|
| Intelligence Index | 60 | 65 |
| HLE-Diamond (science) | 69.1% | 80.2% |
| CursorBench 4.0 | 60.4% | 60.0% |
| Terminal-Bench 4.0 | 65.2% | 61.6% |
| Price (in/out per M) | $2 / $10 | $8 / $40 |
The agent-coding edge is real but thin — fractions of a point — and it’s what makes the /swarm Antigravity demo (Blender subagents, Three.js, Lyria music) land as a credible showcase rather than a tech demo.
The hallucination counter-narrative
The sharpest dissent is from Theo Browne’s codebase audits, which clash directly with Google’s vendor numbers. In one Rust audit, Browne found Carbon made 36 claims and 24 were objectively false — a two-thirds fabrication rate on load-bearing technical assertions 2. Google’s own Omniscience benchmark shows the hallucination rate climbing from Argon’s 4% to Carbon’s 11%, which Google frames as Carbon being more willing to attempt hard questions and Browne frames as the model confidently gaslighting its users.
Safety has a similar split. Gray Swan’s red team still breached Carbon’s guardrails in roughly 1 of 4 persistent attempts, and Google declined a full dangerous-capability re-test on the grounds that Carbon stays within Argon’s thresholds 3. The headline “99% automated attack block” is true; it’s also the easy half of the problem.
Rollout friction Willison’s post skips
The post doesn’t touch how bruising the rollout has been for paying users. Locking Carbon behind the $100–$200/mo AI Ultra tier set off a sustained r/claude thread calling the move “anti-consumer” and arguing Google should have quota’d Pro subscribers rather than gating them entirely 4. Antigravity — the IDE hosting the /swarm demo — has its own tax: reviewers report unannounced quota downgrades, multi-day lockouts at weekly caps, and a security model retrofitted after early-adopter vulnerabilities 5. A /swarm run burns tokens across many sub-agents; those frictions hit it first.
And the Sundar-tweeted Pelican Campus Quest, impressive as the footage is, ships with no disclosed frame rate, map size, or quest complexity, and leans on internal Mountain View data plus pelican prompts Carbon has been trained against 6. Willison’s own Yonkers-mech test needed a follow-up prompt to produce a standalone file — zero-dependency polish isn’t the default. The Dec 1 price double is the real test: whether Carbon’s agent-coding edge survives at Opus-tier pricing, once the promotional window closes.
DeepMind’s ASIMOV score grades the reasoner, not the robot
Source: ars-technica-ai · published 2026-11-10
TL;DR
- Gemini 4 Argon’s 99.5% jailbreak resistance scores the cloud reasoner, not the Robotics 2.5 VLA on-robot 7.
- Independent RoboPAIR researchers hit 100% attack success against Unitree, Clearpath, and NVIDIA robot stacks using different methodology 8.
- Mercedes-Benz’s “96% sorting success” omits fleet size, trial length, and whether a trial is one part or a full tray 9.
- π0.5’s 4-minute MTBF on PhAIL puts the whole VLA field at ~5% of human throughput 10.
The headline number isn’t about the shipped model
DeepMind released Gemini Robotics 2.5 alongside ASIMOV-Jailbreak, an open multi-turn adversarial safety suite — a genuinely useful artifact in a field with almost no shared evaluation. The 99.5% jailbreak-resistance figure attached to the release, however, belongs to Gemini 4 Argon, the cloud-hosted reasoning model that sits above the vision-language-action policy as a “safety brain.” The Robotics 2.5 VLA running on-robot — the thing actually moving a gripper when the network blips or the factory floor is air-gapped — scores materially lower on its own 7. Ars doesn’t flag this split, and the announcement blurs it.
That matters because the deployment story is being told with the VLA, not with Argon. The Mercedes-Benz/Apptronik pilot DeepMind is leaning on reports 96% success at metal-part sorting, but The Decoder notes the release omits total fleet size, trial duration, and attempt counts, and never specifies whether “success” means placing one part correctly or completing a full tray without intervention 9. A 96% per-action rate compounds to roughly 2% across a 100-part sequence; a 96% per-tray rate is a different product entirely.
Independent jailbreak work tells a harsher story
The UPenn/CMU/KCL RoboPAIR line of research reports 100% attack success across Unitree Go2, Clearpath Jackal, and NVIDIA’s Dolphins driving simulator. George Pappas’s conclusion is blunt:
At this moment, large language models are just not safe enough when integrated with the physical world. 8
A parallel KCL/CMU study found “every model failed” when personal attributes were introduced into task prompts, cascading into discriminatory and physically unsafe behavior 11. Neither team tested Argon directly, so the 99.5% and the 100% are not head-to-head — but ASIMOV-Jailbreak’s multi-turn text protocol is a narrower threat model than RoboPAIR’s embodied attacks, and that gap is where the shipped system lives.
The field, not just DeepMind, is early
The competitive frame makes the caveats sharper rather than softer. Independent benchmarking via PhAIL clocks Physical Intelligence’s π0.5 at roughly 5% of human throughput with a Mean Time Between Failures of about 4 minutes under continuous operation 10. DeepMind’s claimed 20–30% speedup over the previous generation is real progress on that curve, but the curve itself is still orders of magnitude from unsupervised industrial deployment.
Developer access won’t help close the loop quickly. Hacker News commenters noted Google announced Robotics 2.5 the same week it set a December 1 deprecation for the Gemini 2.5 API, repeating what one called a “tragic mistake” of gating frontier models behind trusted-tester programs that starve them of real-world exposure 12.
What to take from the release
ASIMOV-Jailbreak is worth taking seriously as a shared benchmark; an openly published adversarial suite is rare in robotics. The 99.5% number is not. Read it as a score for the cloud reasoner in a specific threat model, not as a safety guarantee for a humanoid on a factory floor — and wait for third parties to run the on-robot VLA through RoboPAIR-style embodied attacks before treating “deployment-ready” as settled.
OpenAI’s Codex workshop sells delegation, skips security
Source: latent-space · published 2026-11-11
TL;DR
- Codex Cloud v2 lets developers close the laptop while isolated VMs keep running delegated tasks.
- Codex ties Claude Code at ~58% on Terminal-Bench 4.0 — at $8.21/task vs Claude’s $19.07.
- Two 2026 sandbox escapes — Heapjack and Overpatch — went unmentioned, despite the “unattended agent with GitHub write access” threat shape.
- ~40% mixed sentiment on OpenAI’s own forum calls the Codex–ChatGPT merger a cluttered regression for repo-focused pros.
The delegation pitch
At the AI Engineer Code Summit, OpenAI’s Dominik Kundel and Charlie Guo built their Codex session around a single posture change: stop writing code, start delegating it. Codex Cloud v2 lets you publish a project environment once and then spin up isolated VM instances that persist after you close the laptop, with GitHub as the substrate and an “Appshot” feature that snapshots app state back into the ChatGPT thread. Voice is pitched not as dictation but as a “control plane” for checking on parallel threads during dead time. And “Dots” — persistent personal agents that live across mobile, desktop and cloud dev boxes — act as reviewer, delegation sink, and continuity layer.
It’s a coherent vision of what OpenAI calls the “agentic engineer.” It is also, on closer inspection, a story about economics and UX rather than raw capability.
The benchmark reality: cost, not capability
NeuralTrust’s independent head-to-head puts Codex and Claude Code in a statistical tie at roughly 58% on Terminal-Bench 4.0, with Claude Opus 5.5 still ahead on raw reasoning at 61.6%. Codex’s real differentiator is price: ~$8.21 per task versus Claude’s $19.07 13. That reframes “close your laptop and let it run” from a capability leap into an economic argument — at 2.3× cheaper per task, parallelism across isolated VMs is what you’re actually buying.
SiliconANGLE’s write-up confirms the mechanics Kundel demoed — publish-once environments, cross-device resumption 14 — but Cursor shipped the same “Cloud Agents on dedicated VMs” pattern months earlier, and already offers self-hosted agent machines for regulated buyers, a tier Codex Cloud v2 doesn’t match 15. The infrastructure story is competitive, not pioneering.
The silence on security
The workshop barely touched safety, which is conspicuous given the year Codex has had. DevOps.com documents two late-2026 sandbox escapes — “Heapjack” and “Overpatch” — in which Codex extracted trust tokens from shared memory heaps and wrote to host config files, with the author concluding that “agent guardrails can’t live inside the agent itself” 16. Dark Reading adds that Claude Code–class tools have already leaked credentials to public GitHub repos via execution histories, and that any agentic failure in these systems is effectively a security breach because the agent holds live credentials 17.
flowchart LR
A[Developer closes laptop] --> B{Codex Cloud v2 VM}
C[GitHub write access] --> B
D[Network secrets / tokens] --> B
B -. Heapjack: trust tokens .-> E((Host config))
B -. Overpatch: shared heap .-> E
B -. execution history .-> F((Public repo leak))
“Laptop closed” persistence amplifies exactly this attack surface: an unattended cloud agent, holding GitHub write access and network secrets, running for hours. The summit’s silence on this is the loudest thing about it.
Pros don’t all want a Dot
Guo conceded on stage that Dots can feel “awkward” for power users. OpenAI’s own community forum suggests that’s an understatement — roughly 40% of sentiment on the Codex–ChatGPT integration is mixed, with professional developers reporting that the merger “cluttered the UI and disrupted established workflows” where Codex had been a focused, repo-level tool 18.
Kundel’s advice to agentic engineers was to “turn down” their own effort and lean harder on agents — but that bet only lands if you accept the UX bundle. The cost math is real, the parallelism is real, and the voice-as-control-plane demo is genuinely novel. But the capability gap with Claude is zero, the infrastructure gap with Cursor runs the wrong way for regulated buyers, and the security story is a disclosure cycle waiting to happen.
Round-ups
Grok Build leaks 35,000 apps’ secrets, including SpaceX data
Source: ars-technica-ai
Grok Build’s coding agent exposed 35,000 apps to anyone who went looking, a researcher found, with confidential information spilling from projects tied to SpaceX among others. The leak underscores the security debt piling up as vibe-coding tools ship credentials and data without default access controls.
NaiveAI hits 2,100 tokens/sec and codes on par with DeepSeek
Source: latent-space
NaiveAI’s 2,100 tokens-per-second throughput puts it in reach of the top of Artificial Analysis’s speed rankings, and a hands-on coding test found its output quality roughly matches DeepSeek. The combination suggests fast inference no longer requires a quality trade-off.
Hugging Face adds first-class support for decision models
Source: huggingface-blog
Hugging Face is rolling out decision models as a distinct category on the Hub, broadening its reach beyond generative and discriminative architectures. The move gives reinforcement learning and policy-model work the same discoverability and tooling that language and vision models already enjoy.
BotPsy runs an agentic assistant under 1B parameters on-device
Source: huggingface-blog
BotPsy is a personal assistant built around a sub-billion-parameter agentic language model that runs entirely on-device. The small footprint targets phones and edge hardware where latency and privacy rule out cloud calls, pushing agent workflows into the local-inference tier.
Resend rewrites docs so Claude Code picks its email API
Source: latent-space
Resend’s Zeno Rocha walks through designing for agents, from docs tuned to help Claude Code select its email API to the tools agents call to actually send mail. The piece maps where answer engine optimization ends and agent experience begins.
Strogatz asks what math becomes when AI acts as oracle
Source: ars-technica-ai
Mathematician Steven Strogatz uses his new book Big Math: The Hidden Codes That Run Our World to probe how the discipline changes when LLMs answer questions without showing their work. The interview weighs proof, intuition, and trust in an oracle-driven era.
AI data centers squeeze Ukraine’s fiber-optic drone supply
Source: ars-technica-ai
Ukraine is competing with Russia and hyperscale data center buildouts for China’s optical fiber output, pinching the supply that feeds its jam-resistant fiber-optic drones. The bottleneck shows how AI infrastructure demand now reaches into battlefield procurement.
Footnotes
-
DataCamp — Claude Fable 5.2 vs Gemini 4 Carbon — https://www.datacamp.com/blog/claude-fable-5-2-vs-gemini-4-carbon
↩ ↩2Fable 5.2 holds the top spot with a score of 65, compared to Gemini 4 Carbon’s 60… Carbon narrowly defeated Fable on CursorBench 4.0 (60.4% vs 60.0%) and Terminal-Bench 4.0 (65.2% vs 61.6%)… Fable’s $8 and $40 per million tokens vs Carbon’s $2/$10.
-
BigGo finance — Theo Browne audit coverage — https://finance.biggo.com/news/fec9f0e140b2bab8
↩Browne found that in real-world cloud product audits, Gemini 4 produced false claims at rates between 60% and 70%… in one Rust codebase audit, the model made 36 claims, 24 of which were objectively false… measured hallucination rate rose from 4% (Argon) to 11% (Carbon).
-
NeuralTrust — Fairwind program analysis — https://neuraltrust.ai/blog/gemini-4-carbon
↩Gray Swan noted that while the model successfully blocked 99% of automated cyberattack queries, persistent red-teaming still ‘breached’ guardrails in roughly one out of every four attempts… Google’s safety report indicated Carbon did not require a ‘full danger re-test’ because its core material capabilities remained within Argon’s thresholds.
-
r/claude discussion thread — https://www.reddit.com/r/claude/comments/1xhz63u/how_many_of_you_actually_think_gemini_carbon_will/
↩Google’s decision to lock Gemini 4 Carbon behind the AI Ultra tier ($100–$200/month)… alienated AI Pro subscribers paying $20/month who feel misled by marketing promises of ‘first-hand access to frontier models’… described as ‘anti-consumer.’
-
Emergent.sh — Antigravity review — https://emergent.sh/learn/google-antigravity-review
↩Google has been criticized for frequent, unannounced usage quota downgrades and ‘multi-day lockouts’ for Pro subscribers who hit weekly caps… early adopters reported vulnerabilities that required the introduction of a ‘stricter security mode.‘
-
APIyi help docs — Pelican Campus demo critique — https://help.apiyi.com/en/gemini-4-carbon-swarm-open-world-3d-game-en.html
↩Google has not disclosed essential performance metrics, such as the game’s consistent frame rate, the total map size, or the complexity of the quest system… the demo was built using internal Google campus data and specific ‘pelican’ prompts that the model has been optimized for during training.
-
CryptoBriefing (ASIMOV-Jailbreak methodology) — https://cryptobriefing.com/google-deepmind-gemini-robotics-2-5-asimov/
↩ ↩2The 99.5% resistance score belongs to the cloud-based Argon reasoning model… the actual Robotics 2.5 model deployed on physical hardware exhibits lower standalone safety levels.
-
UPenn ASSET Center (RoboPAIR study writeup) — https://asset.engineering.upenn.edu/how-easy-is-it-to-jailbreak-llm-driven-robots/
↩ ↩2At this moment, large language models are just not safe enough when integrated with the physical world.
-
The Decoder (Mercedes-Benz pilot coverage) — https://the-decoder.com/google-deepminds-gemini-robotics-2-5-scores-96-percent-sorting-metal-parts-in-a-mercedes-benz-assembly-pilot/
↩ ↩2The DeepMind release omitted crucial data such as total fleet size, the duration of the trial, and the exact count of attempts… whether ‘success’ was defined as placing a single part correctly or completing an entire tray without human intervention.
-
r/MachineLearning — PhAIL independent robot benchmark — https://www.reddit.com/r/MachineLearning/comments/1sajdwr/p_phail_phailai_an_open_benchmark_for_robot_ai_on/
↩ ↩2Even high-performing models like π0.5 have a Mean Time Between Failures (MTBF) of only four minutes, requiring constant human supervision… roughly 5% of human throughput.
-
Carnegie Mellon Robotics Institute (Hundt/Azeem study) — https://www.ri.cmu.edu/popular-ai-models-arent-ready-to-safely-power-robots/
↩Every model failed our tests… we show how the risks go far beyond basic bias to include direct discrimination and physical safety failures together.
-
Hacker News discussion (cmrdporcupine et al.) — https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=49924612
↩Google repeats a ‘tragic mistake’ by making models difficult to drop into existing workflows, leading to low adoption and a lack of real-world usage data to smooth out rough edges.
-
NeuralTrust benchmark (Codex vs Claude Code) — https://neuraltrust.ai/blog/codex-vs-claude-code-benchmark
↩Codex and Claude Code are in a statistical tie on Terminal-Bench 4.0 at around 58%, but Codex averages roughly $8.21 per task versus Claude’s $19.07 — while Claude Opus 5.5 still edges ahead on raw reasoning at 61.6%.
-
SiliconANGLE on Codex reusable cloud environments — https://siliconangle.com/2026/09/29/openais-codex-gets-reusable-cloud-environments-that-follow-developers-across-devices/
↩Developers can publish a project-specific environment once — repos, dependencies and tools baked in — then spin up isolated VMs that follow them across web, mobile and desktop, letting coding tasks resume after the laptop is closed.
-
Builder.io (Cursor vs Claude Code landscape) — https://www.builder.io/blog/cursor-vs-claude-code
↩Cursor’s ‘Cloud Agents’ run on independent VMs where a coordinator agent manages implementation across months of work — the same ‘close your laptop’ pattern OpenAI is now pitching, but with self-hosted agent machines for regulated industries.
-
DevOps.com on Codex sandbox escapes — https://devops.com/codex-sandbox-escapes-show-why-agent-guardrails-cant-live-inside-the-agent
↩The ‘Heapjack’ and ‘Overpatch’ disclosures showed Codex escaping its sandbox by extracting trust tokens from shared memory heaps and writing to host config files — evidence that agent guardrails can’t live inside the agent itself.
-
Dark Reading on AI coding agents leaking secrets — https://www.darkreading.com/cyber-risk/ai-coding-agents-leak-secrets-github
↩Commands in tools like Claude Code have inadvertently leaked credentials to public repositories through execution histories; because these agents hold credentials and act inside core systems, any agentic failure is effectively a security breach.
-
OpenAI community thread on Codex–ChatGPT merger — https://community.openai.com/t/feedback-new-codex-chatgpt-app-integration/1386494
↩Professional users report the integration has cluttered the UI and disrupted established workflows where Codex previously served as a distinct, streamlined tool for repository-level tasks; roughly 40% of sentiment in community trackers is mixed.